Jump to content

User:Jéské Couriano/ArbEnfCount/ArchiveGroups/170s

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Legend
Blk TBan Warn NEA Decl Acpt PLS Misc NV PE STL WD NOR
Block Topic-ban Warning Non-enforcement Declined appeal Accepted appeal Page-level sanction Misc. Moot/not a violation Procedural error Inconclusive Withdrawn Other decline reason
Archive no. Sanctions total Thread Arb case Date of last post Sanctions applied Summary Notes
171 2 blocks
2 warnings
1 miscellaneous
1 moot/not a violation
1 not acted on for other reasons
Nado158 MAC Apr. 19, 2015 Nado158: Block (1mo) Blk N/A
Darkness Shines IP Apr. 21, 2015 -nil- NOR Thread summarily closed as filed by an obvious sockpuppet.
Iantresman PS Apr. 21, 2015 Iantresman: Warned to adhere to topic ban Warn N/A
Arzel AP Apr. 28, 2015 Arzel: Warned against gaming the limits of their topic-ban Warn Thread was held in abeyance while a related thread at Clarification was live.
Eric Corbett GGTF Apr. 29, 2015 Eric Corbett and Lightbreather: Mutual interaction ban (indef) Misc The original complaint was deemed to be more-or-less frivolous, but it was noted Eric Corbett's and Lightbreather's interactions were problematic and so an interaction ban was placed.
Ranze GG May 01, 2015 Ranze: Block (2w) Blk Ranze's creation of a redirect to an article unambiguously in the GG area made a better case for sanctions than the edits in controversy, which were mostly related to the men's rights movement and not (at the time) part of GG's topic area.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Parishan AA2 May 03, 2015 -nil- NV Sanction being appealed lapsed on its own terms while thread was active.
172 1 block
1 topic-ban
1 non-enforcement action
2 page-level sanctions
1 not acted on for other reasons
C1cada AA2 May 07, 2015 C1cada: Ban from Armenian Genocide topic area (6mo) TBan N/A
Ohconfucius FLG May 07, 2015 User:Ohconfucius/essay/Editing Falun Gong articles on Wikipedia/user analysis: Deleted
User:Ohconfucius/essay/Editing Falun Gong articles on Wikipedia: Deleted
PLS x2 N/A
Xtremedood IP May 12, 2015 Xtremedood: Block (48h, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
TheRedPenOfDoom GG May 13, 2015 -nil- NOR Thread filed by an unregistered user with no discernible history in the topic area; closing administrator noted that this was likely a user who was active or sanctioned in the topic area due to the history of the GG area, the vague nature of the request, and the fact the page in dispute and its talk page were both semi-protected.
TheRedPenOfDoom, second filing GG May 14, 2015 Retartist (filer): Block (1mo) Blk Foot-shot; thread filed by a user topic-banned from the area, and was largely a rehash of the thread immediately prior.
173 2 page-level sanctions
3 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
Roscelese C&S May 16, 2015 False accusation of rape: "Consensus required" sanction (indef) PLS Page-level sanctions levied under GG as the issues were determined to stem from the editors on that page, of which Roscelese was only one, having trouble achieving consensus.
TheRedPenOfDoom, third filing GG May 17, 2015 Gamergate controversy and its talk page: 500/30 restriction (indef) PLS "There's some merit to the complaint about [TheRedPenOfDoom]'s behavior, but there are also a valid point about what appears to be efforts by those who don't necessarily have Wikipedia's goals in mind to exploit a soft spot in Wikipedia's editing model. ...I'm considering the option of placing the Gamergate controversy article and its Talk page under special page-level sanctions that would increase the editor qualifications requirement from the current 10 edits/4 days to something like 500 edits/30 days[.]" --Zad68, 16:57 May 15, 2015
Debresser PIA May 19, 2015 -nil- NV Subject self-reverted and went to the talk page of the article in dispute.
Hell in a Bucket GGTF May 23, 2015 -nil- NV Reverted edits at locus of dispute had to be suppressed as extreme BLP violations.
Erlbaeko GS/SCW May 27, 2015 -nil- PE Filer was seeking sanctions for breaches of a community-authorised sanctions regime.
OccultZone OZ (premature) May 27, 2015 -nil- NV Filer was seeking enforcement of a temporary injunction. Responding administrators opted to defer to ArbCom/clerks for enforcement.
174 2 blocks
2 non-enforcement actions
2 declined appeals
1 procedural error
1 inconclusive
1 not counted as not a request
Darkness Shines IP May 27, 2015 Darkness Shines: Block (1yr + indef) Blk (N.B.: "1 yr + indef" means the sanctioned user is blocked indefinitely, with the first year as arbitration enforcement.)
Eric Corbett GGTF May 28, 2015 Eric Corbett: Block (1w) Blk N/A
The Gamergate hatting thing has blown up again GG May 24, 2015 -nil- PE Thread was a meta-discussion about talk headers and collapsibles and was forcibly moved to the proper venue.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Handpolk GG June 08, 2015 Gamergate controversy: 500/30 restriction remains in place Decl Appeal was against the 500/30 on Gamergate controversy and its talk page.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Noughtnotout IP June 08, 2015 Noughtnotout: Ban from the Dawoodi Bohra remains in place Decl As noted by responding administrators, Noughtnotout appeared to be a single-purpose account and had hardly edited since their topic-ban was imposed.
No More Mr Nice Guy PIA June 08, 2015 -nil- STL Sole responding administrator was not convinced there was any violations.
Humbugask GG June 17, 2015 Humbugask: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Entire contributions history was calling Wikipedia fascist while liberally adding biographical violations.
Request for exception to 500/30 editing rule on Gamergate GG June 17, 2015 FDJK001 (filer): Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Foot-shot; filer was found attempting to game extended-confirmation and indefinitely blocked as a result.
Why This Matters -- June 21, 2015 -nil- -- Not a legitimate request; this is an attempt at emotional blackmail by MarkBernstein, who was once again the subject of an AE thread at the time this was posted (Archive 175#MarkBernstein).
175 2 topic-bans
1 successful appeal
1 page-level sanction
1 procedural error
MarkBernstein GG June 22, 2015 All GG-related biographies: CRASHlock (indef)
Handpolk (filer): Ban from GG area (indef)
TBan, PLS Thread is ~67% of the archive; most of it is, as one would expect from a massive thread of this nature, accusations, counter-accusations, and rehashing of the underlying content disputes. The thread was by and large considered to be frivolous with respect to MarkBerman as filed, with the filer Handpolk being seen as more problematic. Further sanctions were discouraged by a threat to drag the situation to the media and apparent evidence of off-wiki coordination, with a suggestion to file a new Arbitration for anything larger in scale.
Unblock request from (IPv4 address starting 84.) PIA June 22, 2015 (The aforementioned IPv4): Block lifted. Acpt N/A
TheRedPenOfDoom GG June 25, 2015 TheRedPenOfDoom: Ban from GG area (indef w/6mo appeal intervals) TBan N/A
J0eg0d GG June 25, 2015 -nil- PE Edits at issue weren't technically covered by GG sanctions.
176 1 topic-ban
1 successful appeal
4 moot/not violations
1 procedural error
1 inconclusive
A Quest For Knowledge CC June 26, 2015 A Quest For Knowledge: Ban from climate change denial topic-area and from Anthony Watts (blogger) (3mo) TBan N/A
Eric Corbett GGTF June 27, 2015 -nil- NV Subject blocked independent of the thread.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Jaqeli AA2 June 29, 2015 Jaqeli: Ban from AA2 area lifted wholesale Acpt This is a revisiting of Jaqeli's topic-ban after a period of time with carevouts (See Archive 167).
Bus stop GG June 29, 2015 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous.
MarkBernstein GG June 30, 2015 -nil- PE Filer was attempting to enforce an Arbitration principle, not a remedy.
DHeyward GG June 30, 2015 -nil- STL Discussion amongst administrators stalled out.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Atsme PS July 02, 2015 -nil- NV Sanction being appealed lapsed on its own terms while thread was active.
TheRedPenOfDoom GG July 03, 2015 -nil- NV Edits being complained about were removing bbiographical violations.
177 2 blocks
1 warning
1 declined appeal
1 miscellaneous
4 inconclusive
2 not acted on for other reasons
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by Handpolk GG July 04, 2015 Handpolk: Ban from GG area remains in place Decl Subject was blocked mid-thread for harassment.
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by TripWire IP July 04, 2015 TripWire: Ban from India-Pakistan relations and Pakistani politics topic-areas remains in place for want of participation STL No input beyond filer.
AllRows4 PIA July 08, 2015 -nil- NOR Formal sanctions considered disproportionate to the breach. (In other words, the breach was so minor/technical in nature that sanctioning the subject was considered unjustifiable.)
Arbitration enforcement action appeal by TopGun IP July 06, 2015 TopGun: Ban from India-Pakistan relations and Pakistani politics topic-areas remains in place due to lack of consensus STL The one commenting administrator noted that TopGun had been edit-warring since the sanction had been issued.
Neptune's Trident GG July 13, 2015 Neptune's Trident: Warned to adhere to topic-ban Warn N/A
Arthur Rubin TPM July 14, 2015 -nil- STL N/A
Collect COL July 14, 2015 Collect: Block (1w), one-way interaction ban from MrX (indef) Blk, Misc N/A
Mass killings under Communist regimes EE July 16, 2015 -nil- STL Request is formatted in a nonstandard fashion due to being an appeal against a page-level sanction (more specifically, requesting that the sanctions on MKUCR be rescinded).
Roscelese C&S July 16, 2015 -nil- NOR Consensus amongst responding administrators were that Roscelese's reverts did not need to be justified as they were reverts of obvious vandalism, and recommended the filer pursue clarification of the remedy as it wasn't clear if the justification requirement applied to what would otherwise be the standard exceptions.
Eric Corbett GGTF July 20, 2015 Eric Corbett: Block (72h) Blk Initial block was 1mo, but it was reduced to 72h to comply with the letter of the sanction. Another responding admin expressed a concern that the filer was using AE to harass Eric Corbett.
178 2 blocks
2 topic-bans
1 warning
3 non-enforcement actions
1 moot/not a violation
1 not acted on for other reasons
NewsAndEventsGuy CC July 23, 2015 -nil- NV Closed because subject went on wikibreak, likely due to the stress.
Wavyinfinity PS July 23, 2015 Wavyinfinity: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA N/A
Debresser PIA July 25, 2015 -nil- NOR Thread deemed to be an attempt to weaponise AE
Citadel48 MAC Aug. 07, 2015 Citadel48: Ban from Bosnia and Herzegovina topic-areas and from marking edits in the MAC area as minor (indef) TBan N/A
Futrell GG Aug. 11, 2015 Futrell: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Aside from their repeated BLP violations during the thread, one user opined the name was likely an attempt at Joe jobbing an anti-men's-rights-activism blogger.
WeijiBaikeBianji R&I Aug. 12, 2015 Talk:Race and genetics: Semi-protection (1mo, non-enforcement) NEA Thread dismissed as a content dispute with respect to WeijiBaikeBianji, but apparent sockpuppetry by unregistered users was noted, leading to the semi-protection of the affected article's talk page.
Gob Lofa TRB Aug. 14, 2015 Gob Lofa: Block (24h), formally warned of TRB sanctions
Mabuska (filer): Block (24h)
Blk x2, Warn N/A
Tillman CC Aug. 14, 2015 Tillman: Ban from CC area (indef w/6mo appeal intervals) TBan N/A
179 1 non-enforcement action
4 moot/not violations
1 inconclusive
Peter Gulutzan CC Aug. 20, 2015 -nil- STL No consensus amongst responding admins for sanctions.
Collect COL Aug. 21, 2015 -nil- NV While there was no agreement on the "why", all responding admins agreed there was no grounds to sanction Collect.
Collect[2] COL Aug. 24, 2015 -nil- NV Thread deemed to be frivolous, and was filed by the same IPv6 user that filed the thread immediately prior.
Dukisuzuki MAC Aug. 24, 2015 Dukisuzuki: Block (indef, non-enforcement) NEA Subject was blocked as a sockpuppet created specifically to pick fights.
Collect[3] COL Aug. 28, 2015 -nil- NV Administrators gave Collect the benefit of the doubt as the edits being conplained about were removing contentious biographical material. A Clarification request was filed while the thread was ongoing.
Lidaz EE Aug. 31, 2015 -nil- NV Subject indefinitely blocked as a sockpuppet independent of the thread
180 1 block
2 moot/not violations
2 not acted on for other reasons
MarkBernstein GG Sep. 05, 2015 -nil- NOR "The person who showed up to claim that mentioning My Little Pony was sexual harassment was the last straw for this admin. Time to close this dog and pony (ha!) show. AE is not entertainment for -chan boards, and further requests on this topic will be accompanied with severe restrictions if possible. I officially admonish parties to heed the wise words of Dumuzid: "(1) Masem: Grow up. (2) Dr. Bernstein: Don't be a jerk."[Links added less the one to Dumuzid's userpage] --Gamaliel, closing thread
WikiMania76 PIA Sep. 06, 2015 -nil- NV Subject self-reverted and in any event had not been formally made aware of sanctions.
Settleman PIA Sep. 06, 2015 -nil- NV Consensus was that, at best, a warning was needed, but there was nothing for any sort of formal sanction.
Bolter21 PIA Sep. 06, 2015 Bolter21: Block (24h) Blk N/A
Arthur Rubin TPM Aug. 31, 2015 -nil- NOR Edits were deemed stale. After the thread close there was a brief discussion on what "stale" meant in an AE context.