User:Mzajac/Kyiv

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Some notes on Kyiv.

Kyiv in historical subjects[edit]

Examples:

Library of Congress Subject Headings[edit]

Referring to “standard histories and scientific studies,” WP:WIAN mentions the Library of Congress Subject Headings. LCSH uses its official romanization Kyïv in subject headings. Academic publishers follow this form in bibliographies, and most of their publications use the simplified form Kyiv in the main text of their books.

  • Kyïv (Ukraine)--History (sh85072293)
  • Kyïv (Ukraine)--History--Revolution, 1917-1921 (sh85072294)
  • Kyïv (Ukraine)--History--Siege, 1941 (sh95002135)
  • Kyïv (Ukraine)--History--Siege, 1943 (sh95002338)

These headings were revised in December 2019.

See LC subject headings search: Kyiv Ukraine History (4), Kyiv Ukraine (20), and compare Kiev.

Ukrainian Kyiv and Russian Kiev[edit]

Of course Kyiv and Kiev are both English spellings of a name, but each is derived from and commonly associated with another language. Nearly every article about the name Kyiv/Kiev confirms this.

The spelling Kyiv corresponds to a transliteration from Ukrainian in seven schemes of twelve for Ukrainian described at Romanization of Ukrainian, or nine of twelve if you count Kyïv. Kiev corresponds to a standard transliteration from Russian Киев (according at least eleven of thirteen systems documented in Romanization of Russian).

  • 2004, Canadian Oxford Dictionary, 2nd ed., Toronto: Oxford University Press:
    Kiev /ˈkiːef/ (Ukrainian Kyiv /ˈkiːɪf/) the capital of Ukraine, an industrial city and port on the Dnieper River; pop. (est. 2001) 2,602,000.
    Kyiv see Kiev.

Webster’s NWCD is the dictionary that the Chicago Manual of Style recommends as the primary source for place names. These are a main entry s.v. “Kyiv” with a cross-reference to its Russian name. The Russian name has a separate entry with a subject label indicating its specific application, and cross-referring to the main entry for the definition.

  • 2018, Webster’s New World College Dictionary, 5th ed., New York: Houghton Mifflin, pp 800, 810:
    Ki·ev (Kēef′, -ev′) Russ. name for KyivKi′ev′an (-ən) n., adj.
    Ky·iv (kēyo͞o) capital of Ukraine, on the Dnieper: Russ. name Kiev.

Per M–W’s (different publisher than the above) help on entries, the key word or signals an equal variant spelling: “these the two spellings occur with equal or nearly equal frequency and can be considered equal variants. Both are standard, and either one may be used according to personal inclination.” The help on usage labels explains that Ukrainian is a subject label “used to indicate the specific application of a word or sense.”

  • Merriam-Webster Online, s.v. “Kiev”, Merriam-Webster:
    Kiev geographical name
    Ki·​ev | \ ˈkē-ˌef , -ˌev, -if; ˈkēv \
    variants: or Ukrainian Kyiv or Kyyiv \ ˈki-​yē-​ü \